Critter Cabana516 E First St
Care & feeding guide

Choosing Hay: Timothy, Orchard, Alfalfa and Meadow

Which hay to buy for rabbits, guinea pigs and chinchillas: timothy and orchard as the everyday base, first, second and third cut, when alfalfa is right, blends, freshness and picky eaters.

For a rabbit, guinea pig or chinchilla, hay isn't a side dish. It's most of what they eat. It wears down teeth that never stop growing and keeps the gut moving.

Grass hay, always full. Alfalfa for the young, nursing or underweight. Everything else on the hay shelf is variety.

At a glance

Hay is the diet

Unlimited, fresh and always there. Never let the rack run empty.

  • Unlimited. Oxbow says hay should be available in unlimited amounts. For rabbits it suggests a pile roughly the size of the animal's body each day.
  • Most of the diet. Makers put hay at about 70% to 90% of what a rabbit, guinea pig or chinchilla eats. Pellets and vegetables are the smaller part.
  • Fresh every day. Small Pet Select says to give a fresh supply at least once a day. Take out hay that's wet or soiled.
  • Hay at the litter box. Rabbits like to eat and go at the same time, so a pile or rack there keeps hay clean and gets it eaten.

Which hay for which animal

Timothy or orchard for every adult. Alfalfa is the exception, not the rule.

AnimalEveryday hayAlfalfa hay
RabbitTimothy or orchard grassYoung rabbits (under about 6-7 months), pregnant or nursing does. Only an occasional treat for healthy adults.
Guinea pigTimothy or orchard grassYoung (Oxbow's young-guinea-pig line is under 6 months), pregnant or nursing. A pinch now and then for adults.
ChinchillaTimothy, or orchard grassAn occasional treat for adults, per Oxbow.
GerbilA handful of timothy or orchard grass every dayAsk us
Hamster, rat or mouseOptional. Oxbow lists grass hay for them, and a little is good for chewingAsk us
  • Not sure when to switch off alfalfa? Our rabbit and guinea pig care sheets say alfalfa is for young, growing, pregnant or nursing animals, and adults move to grass hay. Ask us if your pet is near that age.
  • Why not alfalfa for adults? It's higher in protein, calcium and calories. The House Rabbit Society says its calcium is two to five times what an adult non-breeding rabbit needs.

For the rest of each animal's day, see our guides on rabbit pellets, guinea pig pellets, chinchilla food, and hamster and gerbil food.

Timothy and orchard grass

Two grass hays, close on the label. Orchard is softer and sweeter.

  • Timothy is the staple. Oxbow calls it the staple grass hay for small herbivores, and Kaytee says it's lower in protein and calcium than alfalfa.
  • Orchard grass has similar fiber and a softer texture. Oxbow describes a sweet flavor. It's a good second hay and often wins over a fussy eater.
  • Mix them. Oxbow suggests combining two grass hays for variety.
  • Read the bag. There's no single timothy number. Protein on timothy bags runs from 6% to 11%, so go by the bag in your hand.
Compare hay: protein and fiber, per the maker's label
HayProteinFiberSizes
Oxbow Western Timothy7.00% min32.00% max15 oz to 50 lb
Kaytee Timothy6.0% min32.0% max24, 48, 96 oz
Small Pet Select Timothy, 1st cut6.99% min36.64% max2 to 40 lb
Small Pet Select Timothy, 2nd cut8.0% min34.0% max2 to 40 lb
Small Pet Select Timothy, 3rd cut11.0% min26.0% max2 to 40 lb
Oxbow Orchard Grass7.00% min32.00% max15 oz to 50 lb
Kaytee Orchard Grass7.0% min32.0% max24 oz
Oxbow Alfalfa16.00% min32.00% max15 oz to 9 lb
Kaytee Alfalfa12.0% min30.0% max24 oz

Figures are each maker's guaranteed analysis. Alfalfa protein runs from 12% to 16% depending on the maker. No maker prints a calcium figure for timothy or alfalfa hay, so the grass-versus-alfalfa difference comes from the makers' own descriptions.

First, second and third cut

A cut is a harvest. Later cuts are leafier and softer. Makers disagree on how much it matters.

A cut is one harvest of the field. Oxbow says one or two cuttings a year is most common, and a third is rare.

  • Small Pet Select sells by cut. It calls 1st cut the stemmiest with the most fiber, 2nd cut leafier with more protein and fat, and 3rd cut the softest, almost all leaf.
  • Oxbow says cut isn't what to base your choice on. It sells early-cut hay and doesn't label by cut.
  • Kaytee's first-cut timothy lists less fiber than its standard timothy. So the cut name alone doesn't tell you how coarse a bag is.

Treat the cut as a texture clue. Small Pet Select suggests stemmier hay for an overweight pet and softer, leafier hay for a thin or picky one. If your pet has tooth or appetite trouble, see a vet before choosing a hay.

Alfalfa: for the young, the nursing and the thin

Alfalfa is a legume, not a grass. Right for growing animals, a pinch for adults.

  • Who it's for. Young and growing animals, pregnant or nursing mothers, and some underweight or elderly animals. Kaytee says it's high in protein, calcium and calories.
  • Healthy adults. Grass hay is the everyday hay. Offer alfalfa as a small treat only. Oxbow says a pinch.
  • Bladder trouble. Alfalfa is the high-calcium hay. Oxbow says it can contribute to sludge over time, and the House Rabbit Society says a direct link hasn't been proven. If your pet has had stones or sludge, your vet decides which hays.
  • Cubes. Alfalfa cubes follow the same rule as alfalfa hay.
  • Moving off alfalfa. Don't switch hays overnight. Mix grass hay in with the alfalfa and shift the balance gradually.

Meadow blends and botanical hay

Blends are variety, not the base. Check the bag for alfalfa or clover.

  • Meadow hay is a mix of grasses. Some meadow and gourmet blends list alfalfa or clover, so they aren't pure grass hay.
  • Botanical hay is timothy with dried herbs and flowers, such as chamomile, lavender and lemon balm. Oxbow says to ask your vet which botanicals suit your rabbit.
  • Toppers are dried herbs and flowers to sprinkle over hay. They're a treat, not a hay. Oxbow says up to 2-3 teaspoons a day, and the fat is higher than in hay.
  • Chinchillas: our care sheet keeps their diet plain. Stick with timothy or orchard grass, and ask us before adding blends or toppers.

Keep it fresh

Sweet grassy smell, green to gold, dry. Musty or completely brown means no.

  • Normal: a spectrum of greens, a little brown leaf, and fine dust at the bottom of the bag. Oxbow says that dust is mostly leaf that has sifted down.
  • Not OK: hay that's completely brown or sun-bleached, hay with a musty or "off" smell, or hay with no smell at all, which can mean it's old.
  • Never feed mould or damp hay.
  • Storage: a cool, dry place out of the sun, in the original box or another breathable container. Small Pet Select advises a box rather than a sealed plastic bag, since trapped moisture grows mould.
  • How long does a bag keep? No maker prints a shelf life. Use the oldest bag first and go by smell.

Picky about hay?

Try a different hay, a different feeder, or hay hidden in a toy. Not eating at all is a vet visit.

  1. Mix a little new hay into the old, so the smell is familiar. Oxbow says to mix new hay with one your pet is used to.
  2. Try a softer or sweeter hay, such as orchard grass or a leafier cut.
  3. Change how it's offered. Oxbow suggests a different feeder, stuffing hay in a chew toy, or hiding it around the habitat.

Setting up hay

A rack at the litter box, a second hay for variety, and a bin for the bag.

  • A hay rack or feeder keeps hay off the floor and out of the toilet corner. Our rabbit care sheet recommends one.
  • A second grass hay for variety.
  • A box or bin with air flow for the bag.
  • Wooden chews for fun. Hay does the tooth work, and chews are extra.

Quick answers

Which hay should I buy? Timothy. Orchard grass is a good second. They're the everyday hays for rabbits, guinea pigs and chinchillas.

How much hay? Unlimited. For a rabbit, a pile about the size of its body each day, topped up fresh.

Which cut? The makers disagree. Cut is a texture clue: stemmier for an overweight pet, leafier for a thin or picky one. Your pet's reaction is the test.

Can an adult eat alfalfa? As a small pinch, yes. The everyday hay for a healthy adult is grass hay.

When do babies switch off alfalfa? Our care sheets say rabbits move to grass hay after about 6-7 months. For guinea pigs, Oxbow's young-pig line is under 6 months. Ask us if you're unsure.

Does alfalfa cause bladder stones? It's higher in calcium. Experts differ on how direct the link is. If your pet has had bladder trouble, ask your vet.

There's dust and brown bits at the bottom of the bag

A little is normal, according to Oxbow. A musty smell is the thing to watch.

My rabbit won't eat its hay

Try orchard grass, a leafier cut, or a new feeder, mixed in with the old hay. If it has stopped eating, call a vet.

Is a hay blend enough? No. Use a plain grass hay as the base, because some blends contain alfalfa or clover.

Shop this

Pick up in store or have it shipped.

Reviewed by our team 2026-11-15. Nutrition figures are each maker's published guaranteed analysis.

Our sister stores

Can’t find it here? Just ask. We’ll check our five sister stores and help you get it. One family, one buying team, since 2003.