Critter Cabana516 E First St
Care & feeding guide

Treats and Chews for Small Pets: What's Safe and How Much

How many treats are too many, which chews and woods are safe, why hay (not a chew) wears teeth, hay-based forage treats, and which sweet treats to skip for each small pet.

Treats and chews are the fun part of a small pet's day. They work best when they stay small and the main diet stays the main diet.

Hay is what wears teeth and feeds the gut. Chews are enrichment, treats are tiny, and some wood and some sweets are never OK.

At a glance

How much is a treat?

A piece or two a day. The makers' own limits are small.

  • The numbers makers give are small. Oxbow says its timothy treats should be no more than 2% of the day's food. The House Rabbit Society puts fruit and treats under 5%, and Oxbow's hamster advice is 5% or less.
  • One outlier. One maker's biscuit bag allows up to 20% of the diet. That's far higher than the others, so we'd go with the small numbers.
  • Hay and water first. Treats don't replace hay. Keep both always available.
  • Off their food? If your pet isn't eating its regular food, hold the treats back. If it has stopped eating hay, that's a vet visit, not a treat.

Treats by animal

Match the treat to the animal. A treat for one can be wrong for another.

AnimalFine as a small treatSkip
RabbitPlain hay-based treats and chews. Carrots and fruit like apple or banana are very sugary, so keep them tiny and occasional.Seed and nut mixes
Guinea pigPlain hay-based treats and willow or apple wood chews. Small pieces of fruit, as a small part of the diet.Mixes with seeds, nuts, corn or dried fruit
ChinchillaPlain wood chews and hay.Fruit, raisins, sugary or honey treats, seeds, nuts
Syrian hamsterMealworms, plain oats, a small piece of fruit now and thenSugary treats
Dwarf hamsterMealworms, plain oats, flax or millet spraysAll fruit, yogurt drops, honey sticks
GerbilDried mealworms, a tiny bit of carrot or broccoli, a small piece of seedless appleCitrus, yogurt drops, honey sticks
RatSmall training rewards, small pieces of fruitSticky foods like chunky peanut butter
MouseTiny bits of vegetable a few times a weekSeed-heavy treats

See our food guides for each animal for the full daily diet: rabbit pellets, guinea pig pellets, chinchilla food, hamster and gerbil food, and rat and mouse food.

Chews are enrichment, not dental care

Hay wears teeth down. A chew gives the chewing instinct somewhere to go.

  • Hay is the tool. Oxbow says the side-to-side chewing on hay is what wears teeth, and chews are a supplement of untreated wood or woven hay. Kaytee calls hay a natural tooth file.
  • Don't trust a "keeps teeth trimmed" claim. Some packages say it. We'd put it as "supports chewing". A chew doesn't prevent or fix tooth problems.
  • Never trim teeth at home. The House Rabbit Society warns that trimming a rabbit's front teeth at home can cause fractures, exposed pulp, abscess and jaw fracture. A rabbit-savvy vet does it.
  • Watch for signs. Oxbow lists eating less, drooling, weight loss, overgrown teeth and lower activity. It advises a vet check at least once a year.

Animals who gnaw include rabbits, guinea pigs and chinchillas first, then hamsters, gerbils, rats, mice and degus. Read each product's species line, because not every chew suits every animal. For example, one Oxbow chew lists rabbits, rats, mice and chinchillas but not guinea pigs.

Safe wood, unsafe wood

Untreated apple, willow and kiln-dried pine are fine. Stone fruit, cedar and painted wood are not.

Safe, per Oxbow

apple, mulberry, pear, kiln-dried pine, birch and willow, dried bamboo from a reputable source, and unprinted cardboard.

Unsafe, per Oxbow

apricot, plum, peach and cherry, citrus, cedar, yew, cypress, juniper, spruce, fresh pine, holly, black locust, hemlock, horse chestnut, oleander and elder. Also plywood (glues and resins), and painted, varnished or chemically treated wood.

  • No sticks from the yard. Oxbow warns backyard branches can carry harmful bacteria or fungus. The House Rabbit Society adds that lawns and gardens can have pesticide hazards.
  • Stone-fruit wood is a split opinion. The House Rabbit Society says apricot and peach branches are safe once cut and dried for a month or more. Oxbow says to avoid all stone-fruit wood. We follow Oxbow, the more cautious advice.
  • Carpet and fabric fibers can cause a blockage, says the House Rabbit Society.

Hay treats and forage

Hay-based treats are the best of the treats. They're still treats.

  1. Break it into small pieces. Small Pet Select says to break treats up and hide them around the cage.
  2. Tuck the pieces in the hay, so your pet has to work for them.
  3. Take out leftovers if they get soiled. Kaytee says to throw out a soiled treat ball.
  • Check the label for sugar. Oxbow's baked bars list cane molasses, and one Kaytee hay treat uses honey. Neither is sugar-free, so stay with the small amounts.
  • Check the species line. A treat made for hamsters or rats may not suit a rabbit or guinea pig, and the other way round. One flower treat made for sugar gliders, birds, rats, hamsters and gerbils lists a red dye and isn't labelled for rabbits or guinea pigs.
  • Nut allergen note. Kaytee's treat bags say they're made in a facility that handles peanuts and tree nuts.
Treat amounts, per the maker's label
TreatAmount, per the maker's label
Oxbow Simple Rewards timothy3-4 pieces a day, and no more than 2% of daily food
Oxbow baked bars1-2 pieces a day
Oxbow Simple Rewards banana1-2 pieces a day
Kaytee Roll 'n' Toss1 ball per animal, no more than twice a week
Kaytee Timothy ShapesUp to 1 shape a day
Supreme Meadow and Orchard Loops2-4 a day
Supreme Garden and Forest Sticks1-2 a day
Small Pet Select Healthy SnackersNo more than 1 a day, and less for gerbils, hamsters, mice and rats
Exotic Nutrition flower treats2-3 times a week, or under 10% of the main diet

Makers don't agree, and these are the makers' own rules, not ours. Follow the bag in your hand, and keep the total small. These treats contain flour, molasses or fruit, so our chinchilla care sheet says to skip them for chinchillas.

Sugary treats

Most treat-aisle sweets are sugar. A hay stick isn't the same as a honey stick.

  • Sugar can upset a rabbit's gut. The House Rabbit Society says most so-called rabbit treats are very sugary, and too much sugar can lead to gut slowdowns.
  • A honey stick isn't a chew. One popular stick is wheat, oats, corn, millet and honey on a wooden center. It's a grain-and-honey treat.
  • Yogurt drops, honey sticks and molasses rings. Our care sheets say they aren't for dwarf hamsters or gerbils. Rats can have yogurt drops sparingly as training rewards.
  • Dyed treats. Read the label's color line on anything bright before it goes to a guinea pig.

Rotate and check

Swap chews weekly, check them daily, and clean them.

  • Rotate chews weekly, says Oxbow, and offer a variety, not one item.
  • Inspect every day, says Exotic Nutrition. Watch your pet at play, and wipe chews with a damp soft cloth.

Quick answers

How many treats a day? A piece or two. Oxbow says its timothy treats should be 2% or less of the day's food.

Do chews keep my rabbit's teeth short? Hay does that. Chews are enrichment, a bonus, and not a replacement for hay.

Is plum or cherry wood safe? We say no. Oxbow lists all stone fruit as unsafe.

Can I use sticks from my yard? No. They can carry bacteria or fungus, and lawns and gardens may have pesticides.

Which chew is best? Untreated apple or willow for most rabbits, guinea pigs and chinchillas. Always check the label's species line.

Can my dwarf hamster have fruit or yogurt drops? No. Try a mealworm, plain oats, or a millet or flax spray.

Can my chinchilla have a treat? Stay with plain wood chews and hay. Our care sheet says sugary treats and fruit cause gut trouble.

How often do I change chews? Rotate weekly, inspect daily.

Should I trim my rabbit's teeth? Never at home. See a rabbit-savvy vet.

My pet won't eat hay but loves treats. Cut the treats back first. If it has stopped eating hay, see a vet.

Shop this

Pick up in store or have it shipped.

Reviewed by our team 2026-11-15. Nutrition figures are each maker's published guaranteed analysis.

Our sister stores

Can’t find it here? Just ask. We’ll check our five sister stores and help you get it. One family, one buying team, since 2003.